Yes/No Popups: 7 Examples to Boost Decision-Making

Table of Contents

Capturing the attention of website visitors is harder than ever. They’re bombarded with campaigns, offers, and choices—making it difficult to decide.

That’s where yes/no popups come in.

Unlike traditional pop-ups with a single call-to-action, yes/no popups present users with a simple choice, giving them control over their experience while gently nudging them toward a decision.

In this article, you’ll learn how yes/no popups work, why they’re effective, and see seven real-world examples that show how brands use them to boost engagement and conversion rates. By the end, you’ll know exactly how to leverage these popups to streamline decision-making, drive sign-ups, and enhance the user experience on your site.

Let’s get started!

What is a yes/no popup?

A yes/no popup is a special type of website popup that presents users with two clear choices: a positive (“Yes”) and a negative (“No”).

Unlike traditional popups that only feature a single CTA (call to action), yes/no popups simplify decision-making by giving visitors a direct choice.

The questions these popups pose are typically straightforward, like “Do you want to save 20% today?” or “Interested in joining our community?”

By offering a direct yes/no question, these pop-ups grab attention and give users an immediate sense of control over their browsing experience.

Moreover, they can be an effective way to grow your email list.

By enticing visitors with appealing offers in exchange for their email addresses, you can seamlessly integrate them into your email list, boosting your potential for future engagement and sales.

Why should you use yes/no popups?

Yes/no popups are more than a gimmick—they’re a smart way to engage with website visitors and segment them effectively. Here’s why:

  • Empower users: By presenting a choice, you give users a sense of control, increasing the chances they’ll engage. It’s not about forcing a decision; it’s about inviting one.
  • Reduce friction: These popups are simple, clear, and to the point. With just two buttons, there’s no overwhelming information. This straightforward format helps visitors make quicker, easier decisions.
  • Insight into behavior: Tracking yes/no responses can provide valuable data. If someone clicks “yes,” they’re interested, allowing further engagement. If they choose “no,” you still gain insights into their preferences.

Additionally, yes/no popups can serve as effective lead magnets by offering valuable resources in exchange for email subscriptions.

By segmenting visitors based on their responses, you can tailor follow-up strategies to better meet their needs and interests.

How do yes/no popups boost conversions and decision-making?

Yes/no popups tap into the framing effect, a psychological principle where people are more likely to make a choice when presented with a simple, clear contrast.

Instead of navigating through long forms or endless options, visitors see a clear path that makes sense and aligns with their expectations. For instance, a user might hesitate to join a mailing list. However, when presented with a simple yes/no popup like “Want to receive insider discounts?” they’re more likely to click “yes” or “no” rather than ignoring it entirely.

These popups don’t just nudge users—they guide them, leading to faster decisions that are often more favorable for the business.

7 yes/no popup examples to inspire you

Now, let’s look at seven brands that have mastered yes/no popups to boost engagement and drive decisions.

1. Hero Pet Health

Hero Pet Health’s yes/no popup is clear and enticing, starting with: “You’ve got $10 off!” Users are given two options: “Claim $10 Off” or “I’m not interested.”

Hero Pet Health home page popup offering a discount.
Hero Pet Health home page popup offering a discount.

This strategy boosted their conversion rates by letting visitors quickly choose between savings or opting out.

2. Eterneva

Eterneva shifts from the traditional pitch with their newsletter popup. Instead of just offering subscriptions, they invite users to “Join the Community.”

Eterneva newsletter popup inviting users to join the community with yes or no choices.
Eterneva newsletter popup inviting users to join the community with yes or no choices.

This subtle approach makes opting in feel more personal and welcoming.

3. The Oodie

The Oodie’s yes/no popup asks, “Who are you shopping for?” allowing visitors to select if they’re shopping for themselves or someone else, then claim a discount by entering their email.

The Oodie’s yes/no popup asking who the visitor is shopping for with clear options.
The Oodie’s yes/no popup asking who the visitor is shopping for with clear options.

4. Mott & Bow

Mott & Bow’s yes/no popup is straightforward, asking, “Want to pay $26 less for our jeans?”

Mott&Bow's popup takes advantage on asking a few questions.
Mott & Bow’s yes/no popup offering a $26 discount with a ‘Yes, please!’ button.

A “Yes, please!” button invites immediate engagement, while the “No, thanks” button allows easy opt-out.

5. Pixie Wing

Pixie Wing adds a sense of mystery and urgency with “You’ve just unlocked an exclusive discount,” followed by the options “Send my code now” or “No, I’d rather pay full price.”

Pixie Wing’s popup announcing an exclusive discount with a send code option.

This popup adds a sense of mystery and urgency, encouraging users to engage out of curiosity.

Pixie Wing’s popup announcing an exclusive discount with a send code option.

6. Sassy Scents

Sassy Scents uses FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) with their full-screen yes/no popup: “You’ve got 15% off—save it before it’s gone!” prompting users to act quickly.

Sassy Scents popup offering 15% off with urgency-driven yes or no buttons

With a clear “Claim 15% Off” button and a secondary “No, I’m thanks” option.

Sassy Scents popup offering 15% off with urgency-driven yes or no buttons

7. Welle Co

Welle Co’s yes/no popup offers a €10 discount for new visitors. With a “Claim Discount” button or a polite “No, Thanks” opt-out, users can easily decide.

Welle Co popup presenting a $10 EUR discount for new visitors with claim or decline options.

It’s an uncomplicated, no-pressure way to boost conversions.

Pre-built yes/no popup templates for website visitors

Want to implement yes/no popups without the hassle of designing them from scratch?

OptiMonk has you covered with customizable templates that make it easy to create effective popups tailored to your brand.

Whether you’re a small business owner or a seasoned marketer, OptiMonk’s templates help you set up attention-grabbing popups that drive conversions and engage visitors effortlessly.

Wrapping up

Don’t underestimate the power of a simple choice. In a world flooded with information, sometimes all a visitor needs is a clear “Yes” or “No.” By implementing yes/no popups, you’re not just improving your website’s user experience—you’re fostering better engagement, gaining valuable insights, and driving more conversions.

Ready to test a yes/no popup on your site?

Create an OptiMonk account, get started, and see how a small change can make a big impact.