- Blog
- How Milk Makeup Built a Beauty Powerhouse Through Bold Strategy and Authenticity
How Milk Makeup Built a Beauty Powerhouse Through Bold Strategy and Authenticity
-
Anna Varga
- Marketing Breakdowns
- 6 min read
Table of Contents
What happens when a beauty brand stops chasing trends and starts building culture?
Milk Makeup answered that by rewriting the rules—loudly, unapologetically, and with purpose.
No outdated ideals. No gender boxes. No ingredient gray areas. Just a bold commitment to clean, expressive, inclusive beauty, built for real people who live creatively.
Milk didn’t earn its cult status by blending in. It did it by making purpose, innovation, and digital fluency non-negotiables.
By 2024, Milk Makeup’s revenue reached $10 million, and the brand saw impressive online sales, with projections of 15-20% growth in 2025 as it continues to innovate and expand its reach.
Let’s break down how Milk Makeup turned creative beauty into cultural impact!
1. Lead with purpose, not just product
Milk Makeup never set out to blend in with the clean beauty crowd. From day one, the brand positioned itself around individuality, freedom, and ethical beauty, not perfection.
They coined the term “beautility”: makeup as a tool for self-expression, not correction. The message was simple but powerful: makeup is for everyone, regardless of gender, skin tone, or aesthetic.
That message landed especially well with their core audience: Gen Z and younger Millennials.
These consumers don’t just want products, they want values. They gravitate toward gender-inclusive, innovative, and cruelty-free beauty, and they see makeup as a way to express who they are, not fit in.
Instead of chasing filtered perfection, Milk made room for real people. And that kind of authenticity? It builds long-term loyalty that traditional branding can’t buy.
2. Use product innovation as a growth engine
In a competitive market, it’s not enough to be clean—you also have to be clever. Milk Makeup mastered this by merging product innovation with cultural relevance.
Take the now-iconic KUSH Mascara, infused with cannabis oil. It wasn’t just a smart formulation, it was a conversation starter. It positioned Milk at the intersection of beauty, pop culture, and science, instantly generating buzz and setting the tone for future launches.
Every Milk product is designed with a modern, ethical consumer in mind:
- 100% vegan
- Paraben-free
- Cruelty-free
- Multi-functional (less waste, more value)
3. Build a community, not just a following
Milk Makeup didn’t build its brand on packaging or price, it built it on culture.
Since day one, it’s been more about storytelling than selling.
Think short films, behind-the-scenes shoots, interviews with NYC creatives, and so on. The brand has always spotlighted real people and real voices, not just polished influencer content.
Diversity isn’t an add-on for Milk, it’s baked in. From gender expression to underground art scenes, the brand stands for showing up exactly as you are. And that message doesn’t just resonate, it sticks.
When they do a collaboration, it feels less like a promotion and more like a cultural moment. Case in point: Cardi B x Milk. Instead of a one-off shoutout, they dropped a curated edit of her actual go-to Milk products during her “Little Miss Drama” tour promo.
@iamcardib @milkmakeup got me right for my "Little Miss Drama" tour announcement shoot with Hydro Grip Gel Tint + a few more of their products. #milkmakeuppartner ♬ original sound - Cardi B
You saw the look, saw the routine, and could buy everything she used. It didn’t just drive buzz, it created a cultural moment with real emotional pull.
4. Take your social seriously
In 2025, social is still Milk’s strongest channel. But this isn’t just about aesthetics. Their strategy is fast, fearless, and fully integrated.
Milk’s content feels native to the platforms it lives on. Whether it’s an Instagram Reel, a TikTok tutorial, or a YouTube short, it’s designed to connect with a digital-first Gen Z and Millennial audience.
Their visuals are bold, experimental, and rooted in NYC energy: CGI, motion graphics, and live footage all in one scroll-stopping package.
@milkmakeup Definition of “I want it, I got it.” New Balmade Electrolyte Lip Balm just dropped EARLY on the @sephora ♬ original sound - milkmakeup
They’re also not afraid to put paid behind what works. Their Facebook and Instagram ad strategy is sharp, data-backed, and built for performance.
With aggressive A/B testing, segmentation, and creative optimization, they don’t just spend, they scale.
They also connect offline and online through OOH x social integrations—turning physical activations into viral moments through influencer content.
Campaigns like the Balmade Lip Balm launch and the St. Vincent “Fearless” series show how they blend storytelling, performance, and personality across platforms. Influencers aren’t just promoting, they’re participating.
@milkmakeup LIVE YOUR LOOK ST. VINCENT At Milk Makeup, we believe it’s not about how you wear your makeup, it’s what you do in it that matters. That’s what our mantra Live Your Look stands for. It’s a call to fearlessly live your truth and own your unique brand of confidence. No one embodies this ethos more than @St. Vincent ♬ original sound - milkmakeup
In short, Milk treats social like a core business function, not a side hustle.
5. Make your website work harder than your ads
Right from the homepage, they put brand value front and center with a dedicated “Award-Winning Clean Beauty” section.
This is smart positioning: instead of simply telling users the products are clean, they show that they’re industry-recognized and trusted. That kind of social proof creates instant credibility.
Then comes the multi-step popup—smooth, well-timed, and actually useful. First it asks for your email, then your phone number, offering a 15% discount in return.
It’s not just a discount strategy, it’s a clever way to layer engagement and build a high-quality list.
And Milk’s product pages? They’re mini-experiences designed to educate, inspire, and convert. For bestsellers, there’s a “Get Ready With Milk” section, showing how the products fit into a routine.
Right below, you’ll find real customer reviews and highlighted ingredients, making the pages both trustworthy and transparent. To increase basket size, each page also includes a “Pairs Well With” section that recommends complementary items, encouraging discovery without feeling pushy.
On top of that, Milk has built a quiz hub where visitors can answer fun questions to learn about the right primers, mascaras, or lip products for them.
At the end of each quiz, users get personalized product matches—and a nudge to subscribe with a discount to unlock their results.
Milk turns every page and every interaction into a guided journey toward purchase.
6. Offer value beyond the cart
Milk Makeup doesn’t just rely on great products to drive loyalty—they back their products with smart, value-driven incentives that keep customers coming back.
Through platforms like Student Beans, they offer a wide range of exclusive discounts for students, healthcare workers, first responders, and more. It’s a strategic move that builds goodwill with key segments and creates habits early.
These aren’t one-off promos, either. The discounts are always on, and cover multiple customer types, making the brand more accessible without cheapening its image.
They also run a subscription model.
With the Subscribe & Save option, returning customers can set up recurring deliveries at a lower price, plus get early access to limited-edition drops. It’s seamless, flexible, and designed for convenience.
And if all that weren’t enough, there’s also the VIP Members loyalty program, designed to turn casual shoppers into true brand fans.
It works on a simple but effective model: every purchase earns points, which can later be redeemed for discounts. But the real pull is in the extras: early access to new launches and exclusive promos reserved only for members.
Wrapping up
Milk Makeup’s growth didn’t happen by chance. The brand knows its audience and speaks to them with clarity and purpose.
By leading with values over vanity, launching products that spark conversations, and weaving storytelling into every channel, Milk has turned beauty into identity.
It’s proof that real success isn’t about flashy packaging—it’s about building community, culture, and loyalty that lasts. From bold social campaigns and a website built for conversions to student discounts and VIP perks, every detail nudges customers toward belonging, not just buying.
The takeaway? Lasting brands don’t chase trends. They build culture, fuel creativity, and give people reasons to return. That’s the real playbook behind a beauty powerhouse.
Learn more
Looking for more marketing breakdowns? Check out these articles:
- Building a Premium Pet Brand: The Marketing Strategy Behind Maev’s Rapid Growth
- How Away Reached $1.4 Billion by Turning Luggage into a Travel Lifestyle
- E.L.F. Cosmetics Marketing Breakdown: A Digital-First Beauty Brand for Gen Z and Millennials
- Skullcandy’s Marketing Breakdown: A Deep Dive into Success
- Native’s Marketing Playbook: How a Deodorant Brand Went From 3D Renders to Retail Giants
Migration has never been easier
We made switching a no-brainer with our free, white-glove onboarding service so you can get started in the blink of an eye.
What should you do next?
Thanks for reading till the end. Here are 4 ways we can help you grow your business:
Boost conversions with proven use cases
Explore our Use Case Library, filled with actionable personalization examples and step-by-step guides to unlock your website's full potential. Check out Use Case Library
Create a free OptiMonk account
Create a free OptiMonk account and easily get started with popups and conversion rate optimization. Get OptiMonk free
Get advice from a CRO expert
Schedule a personalized discovery call with one of our experts to explore how OptiMonk can help you grow your business. Book a demo
Join our weekly newsletter
Real CRO insights & marketing tips. No fluff. Straight to your inbox. Subscribe now
Share this article
Written by
You may also like
- Posted in
- Marketing Breakdowns
Product updates: January Release 2025
